What If One Capital Campaign Priority Is Funded and Another Isn’t?

Capital campaigns often begin with a burst of energy and several large gifts from committed donors. But after a few years, a team may find itself meeting month after month to discuss the same prospects without much new progress.
That can happen when a campaign includes several projects. One building may be complete while others still need funding. In that situation, it may help to look at the remaining work project by project.
Reframe the Amount That Remains
Imagine an $8 million campaign that has raised $6 million. The first building is complete, but several other building projects are still in the planning stages. Rather than treating the remaining $2 million as one large, abstract gap, break it down by the work it will fund.
The campaign team might create a new gift range chart and depth chart for the remaining $2 million. A focused case for support can show donors what each project will accomplish and what it will take to move it forward.You can also look at whether a challenge gift might encourage new support. For example, a donor might offer up to $500,000, giving $1 for every $2 in qualifying gifts. To receive the full match, the campaign would need to raise $1 million in gifts that meet the challenge terms.
Decide Which Project is Ready to Advance
The next project to feature does not have to be the largest or most exciting one. It should be a project the organization can explain clearly and is prepared to carry out. Ask:
- Is the project’s scope clear?
- Is its cost estimate current?
- Is there a realistic timeline?
- Does it depend on another project being completed first?
- Can the organization explain who will benefit and how?
- Is there a timely reason to bring it to donors now?
For example, the education center may need less than $500,000 to complete its funding. It has a specific case and construction schedule, making it a concrete opportunity to present to donors. The visitor center may be better to highlight during the busy tourist season, when many people are on site and can see the organization’s work firsthand.
The team can focus on the education center now while preparing for the visitor center’s fundraising opportunity later. A project that needs more planning can remain part of the campaign vision without becoming the immediate focus of donor conversations.
Build the Campaign Project by Project
When a campaign supports several distinct projects, donors may respond more readily to a specific opportunity than to a large remaining balance. They can see what a gift will help make possible and why that work matters.
One organization raising money for several building projects completed the first building while others were still being planned. Rather than continue talking only about the full campaign goal, the team looked at the funding still needed for each project. The education center needed less than $500,000. It had a clear case and construction schedule. The visitor center had a natural fundraising moment during tourist season.
This kind of project-by-project approach can also help an organization pursue more than its original estimate. One campaign that had been expected to raise no more than about $2.8 million ultimately raised $4.2 million over three or four years. The organization broke the work into specific projects and raised money for them one at a time.
Keep Each Project Connected to the Larger Vision
A project-specific case should make the opportunity clear, but it should also explain how the project fits the campaign’s overall purpose. If every project sounds like a separate appeal, donors may wonder whether the organization has changed its plans.
Show what the campaign has already accomplished, what the next project will make possible, and how the remaining projects contribute to the same vision. The education center and visitor center may serve different purposes, but both can be part of a larger plan to improve the organization’s campus and community impact.
Don’t Get Stuck in the Original Campaign Framework
The approach that helped secure the largest early gifts may not be the best approach for the campaign’s final stretch. Early on, the team may have focused on a major goal and a small group of lead donors. Later, a specific project with a clear cost, case, and schedule may be more compelling than another broad appeal to complete the overall goal.
The campaign does not need to abandon its original vision. It can keep the larger goal in view while giving donors a clear opportunity to help complete the next piece of the work.
When one campaign project is funded and others still need support, look at what remains, decide which project is ready to advance, and give donors a clear picture of what their support can accomplish. Breaking the work down project by project can help the team find fresh energy and move the full campaign forward.
Free Campaign Checklist & Guide
Download our free capital campaign checklist and guide to learn exactly what’s required for each phase of your campaign.


Leave a Comment